Submit comment Remove comment

To

Toni Erdmann (OSM: ToniE) reply

I maintain a collection of GTFS-feed which are - from license perspective - compatible with OpenStreetMap. [PTNA](https://ptna.openstreetmap.de) actually take the data and aggregates that to better fit the needs of OSM - remove trips which are from shape perspective identical and differ only in departure_time. @[GitHub](https://github.com/osm-ToniE/gtfs-feeds), you'll find a set of files for each feed, including a "get-release-url.sh"

26 Feb 2024 08:44 UTC

ra

random guy from Wrocław reply

and why this comments section ignored all the formatting I've done???

25 Feb 2024 17:38 UTC

ra

random guy from Wrocław reply

You are doing an interesting project, that need some contribution, so not only there is the application, but also data. I've never heard about GTFS, so I've searched in the internet if there is such option for city where I live (Wrocław, PL). And it is. Well, in lot's of the places… So, there is an official website cities domain, where you can find GTFS file. But there are also lot's of databases wich such files for regions from all around the world. I mean, I don't know what exactly is going to be in your but for me it looks like there are alread such DB-s. Do I understand that correctly? Or you are doing something different, and you have to create a new DB from the beginning? Or you didn't know about existing DB-s and that's why you started doing a new one? A few examples: - official one: https://opendata.cui.wroclaw.pl/dataset/rozkladjazdytransportupublicznegoplik_data - one DB found on the internet: https://github.com/MobilityData/mobility-database-catalogs - …and another one: https://transitfeeds.com/p/mpk-wroc-aw/663 - …and another one: https://gtfs.pro/ PS Your security question are terrible… I've already done 5 mistakes and I'm pretty sure free chatgpt would give better answers than me. And why the color???

25 Feb 2024 17:37 UTC

Jo

Jonah Brüchert ✔️ reply

You are right, there are existing collections of these feeds, but feeds overlap and very in quality. That's why it is needed to choose which feeds we want to add. The actual url and metadata can still be taken from an existing collection, but there is some curation needed. Sorry about the formatting, this comment system is very simple and self-built :)

25 Feb 2024 18:27 UTC

ra

random guy from Wrocław reply

I see, thank you What / where in this is MOTIS?

25 Feb 2024 18:30 UTC

Jo

Jonah Brüchert ✔️ reply

MOTIS is the software doing the core of the work, that is reading the GTFS files from disk and finding the routes. Transitous is about making it run reliably and hosting it for the general public.

25 Feb 2024 18:35 UTC

comments privacy policy